"Dispropaganda" - An independent and politically unbiased website which strives to tell historical, political and contemporary, unfashionable, hidden truths through the use of satire and black humor.

Please reload

D'Day wasn't responsible for the defeat of Nazi Germany, the USSR was.

June 6, 2018

Despite the popular belief that because of D-Day, the US and the western allies won WW2 in Europe, the truth is that WW2 had already been won in Europe by Soviet Russia when it defeated the German army in the eastern front.

By 1944, Nazi Germany had already lost the war to the Soviet Union, which had basically annihilated the Wehrmacht in the eastern front and the Red Army was racing its way towards Berlin, with the German army unable to hold it off, and barely able to offer up any meaningful resistance.

Just to put things into perspective, while the Red Army suffered enormous losses of 8.7 to over 10 million military deaths during the war, The Red Army was also responsible for around 80% of all German Combat casualties in WW2

Almost 4 million Third Reich troops went into the eastern front to fight against Soviet Russia, while by the time the western allies landed in Normandy all that was facing them was around 50,000 German soldiers. 

By the time the western allies showed up in Normandy on 6 June 1944, all that was left facing them was a small number regular German divisions.

On the whole the Germans had some 26 divisons left in western front that were bolstered by what was mostly German teenagers and senior citizens who had little or no training, and even then the allies were having great difficulties in defeating them and pushing into Germany.

Now compare that with the fact that the USSR had to face and defeat around 214 German divisons on the Eastern front, comprised of the the very best the German army had offer in terms of men and equipment, and you get the real perspective on D'day and on the war in Europe as a whole.

The western allies, as the historian Professor Norman Davies notes, were a "peripheral sideshow" in the European theater of war.


 

 Captured German boy soldiers
.

Many in the west argue that "Lend- Lease" was what saved the USSR in 1942, and allowed them to win the war. In reality however, the Soviets had already gained the upper hand on their own account befor Western aid began to reach them in serious quantity.

The Arctic convoys that were sent from Britain to Murmansk, beginning in 1941, were extremely perilous and hardly defensible in terms of tonnage delivered against tonnage lost. They were a bold gesture of solidarity from the western allies to Soviet Russia, but hardly a game changer and certainly not what "saved" the USSR from Nazi Germany.

By 1942 Soviet military production had almost quadrupled then in 1941, despite the German invasion in the USSR, and was well equipped to supply the Red Army with all the tanks, planes and heavy guns they required.

The critical years for the Soviet Union did not start in 1943 when Lent Lease was coming on full stream, but in 1941-2, when Western aid was still marginal. At that juncture, the Red Army faced the full brunt and might of the invincible German army; yet it did not run short of weapons or munitions, and in spite of everything, it did hold out.

What is more, much of the early Lend-Lease aid was unusable. For example: British tanks were not what the Red Army needed, and British Army greatcoat (like German greatcoats) were totally unsuited to the Russian winter.

On the whole US Lend Lease to the USSR accounted for around 6% of the total Soviet war production/effort during WW2.


 

 

 

 

The western allies landing in Normandy on June 6 1944 was not the reason why Nazi Germany was defeated, the USSR had already defeated it and was racing to Berlin by that time.

The western allies goal was also not to free the whole of Europe from tyranny, because FDR and Churchill had already agreed in the 1943 Teheran conference that Stalin could and would occupy everything but Western Europe.

The western allies main goal in D-Day was to make sure that Soviet Russia would not overrun the WHOLE of Europe, and to make sure that at least western Europe would remain free of a Soviet occupation.This was infact the main reason for D-Day, because if it wasn't for D-Day, the whole of Europe would probably end up under Soviet occupation.

 

  Stalin, FDR and Churcill, 1943, Teheran.


But while the Western allies saved Western Europe from the hordes of marauding and raping barbarian Red Army troops, they were happy with letting Stalin and the USSR oocupying the rest of it.

At the end of WW2, most of Europe, instead of being liberated from tyranny, would continue to live under a brutal dictatorship right up until the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991.



Bibliography -



Norman Davies, "No simple victory."

Laurence Rees , "World War II Behind Closed Doors."

Anthony Beever, "Stalingrad."



 

 

Please reload

FEATURED POSTS
Please reload

SEARCH BY SUBJECTS